Is Temu the Next Shein — or the End of Online Shopping as We Know It?

Source: The China Project

If you've never heard of Temu, you're probably not on TikTok. The ultra-budget shopping app has exploded into the global e-commerce space like a discount-fueled meteor, promising you can “shop like a billionaire” for RM5 gadgets, RM10 earrings, and mystery boxes for less than lunch.

But behind the cheap thrills and irresistible deals lies a bigger question: Is this the future of shopping—or the beginning of its collapse?

Temu’s Meteoric Rise: How Did It Happen So Fast?

Launched in September 2022 by PDD Holdings—the same Chinese tech giant behind Pinduoduo—Temu set out to dominate international markets with a formula of rock-bottom prices, direct-from-factory shipping, and viral marketing. Within a year, it had surpassed Amazon, Walmart, and Shein in app downloads in the U.S.

Temu uses a cross-border, factory-to-door model, cutting out middlemen and drastically reducing prices. Unlike traditional platforms, it doesn’t store inventory. Instead, it acts as a chaotic digital bazaar, connecting consumers directly with Chinese manufacturers.

Even more aggressively, Temu burns through cash to acquire users, spending millions on Super Bowl ads, TikTok influencer campaigns, and YouTube pre-rolls, promising once-in-a-lifetime deals, over and over again.

Temu is often compared to Shein, and for good reason. Both rely on:

• Hyper-consumption at scale

• Low production costs in Chinese factories

• Ultra-fast delivery systems (with caveats)

• Algorithmic targeting of Gen Z shoppers

But where Shein sticks to fashion, Temu is everything: gadgets, pet toys, fake plants, shoes, kitchen gear, makeup, headphones, and often at a fraction of the cost of any competitor. It’s like Amazon and Mr. DIY had a baby… in a factory with no safety standards.

The Ethical Cost of Cheap

As Temu floods the market with shockingly cheap items, experts are raising serious red flags:

• Labour Conditions: Many Temu suppliers operate in opaque factories with little visibility into working conditions. There are rising concerns about exploitation, wage violations, and zero-hour contracts.

• Environmental Impact: Products are manufactured at scale with minimal regulation, creating an unsustainable loop of overproduction, waste, and carbon-heavy shipping. Most items are single-use or disposable.

• Data Privacy & Counterfeits: U.S. lawmakers have already questioned Temu's data privacy practices. Some listings are allegedly counterfeit or knockoffs, raising IP infringement concerns and risk for consumers.

• Consumer Manipulation: Temu's gamified UX (daily check-ins, coins, roulette spins) promotes impulse buying through dopamine-fueled microtransactions, resembling behavioural addiction more than shopping.

Temu vs. Traditional E-commerce: A Wake-Up Call?

Temu’s rise could signal something deeper: a breaking point in how we consume.

Platform	Strengths	Weaknesses
Temu	Ultra-low prices, wide product range, addictive UX	Ethical issues, questionable product quality, and long shipping
Shein	Trendy fashion at low prices	Labour controversies, environmental damage
Amazon	Reliable delivery, established ecosystem	Higher costs, slower to adapt to Gen Z
Shopee/Lazada	Regional convenience, varied pricing	Less aggressive globally

Temu doesn’t just compete—it rewrites the rules, prioritising volume over value, virality over trust, and cheapness over everything.

What This Says About Us (and What Comes Next)

Temu's success is a mirror held up to our faces. We want ethical products… but also RM2 deals with free shipping. We support small businesses… but we love convenience. We worry about the planet… while checking out our eighth Temu parcel.

In the long run, this model may not be sustainable—economically, ethically, or environmentally. But for now, it works, and millions of consumers are hooked.

Temu might not just be the next Shein. It could be the Amazon of Gen Z, or the canary in the coal mine for how broken online shopping has become.

References:

1. CNN Business – “Temu is the No. 1 shopping app in the US. Here's what to know”:https://edition.cnn.com/2023/06/21/business/temu-shopping-app-rise

2. Vox – “Temu, Shein, and the messiness of online ultra-fast fashion”:https://www.vox.com/the-goods/23740752/temu-fast-fashion-ecommerce

3. Business Insider – “Temu is wildly cheap. Here's what to know about the Shein rival”:https://www.businessinsider.com/what-is-temu-cheap-shopping-app-ethics-shein-2023-5

4. Rest of World – “Inside Temu, the wildly popular shopping app”:https://restofworld.org/2023/temu-explainer/

5. Forbes – “What Is Temu and Is It Legit?”:https://www.forbes.com/sites/qai/2023/09/15/what-is-temu-and-is-it-legit/

6. Wired – “Is Temu too good to be true?”:https://www.wired.com/story/temu-app-shopping-fast-fashion/

The Uncommon Breed

---